The symptoms of whiplash or cervical acceleration/deceleration (CAD) injury are very often referred to as "bizarre," particularly by authors not thoroughly familiar with the condition.
Most of us have developed methods of coping with our patients' difficult, but otherwise benign, questions. "Gee doctor, when you pushed on my right knee, I felt it behind my left ear. Why is that?" We then mumble something about how we expected that and then proceed with our examination and treatment of the patient. Don't get me wrong here, I'm not suggesting that your patients' input or questions are not important but there are times ... Other times, however, our patients have legitimate concerns and do require thoughtful answers. When cases are litigated we may find ourselves responding to questions under cross-examination or in a deposition about why a patient is in pain or is dizzy. This article will review what we do know about the signs and symptoms of CAD trauma.
Symptoms and Signs
Table I list the 14 most frequently described complaints in CAD trauma. Note that some may be related to the postconcussion syndrome, the Barre-Lieou syndrome or TMJ dysfunction.
Common Symptoms Following Whiplash in Order of Prevalence
Facial pain and TMJ related symptoms
(clicking, closed lock, etc.)+
Auditory symptoms (phonophobia,
tinnitus, loss of hearing)*@+
Ocular dysfunction (blurred vision,
* May be part of PCS
@ May be part of Barre-Lieou syndrome
+ May be part of TMJ dysfunction
Neck pain is easily explained by tearing of any soft tissue, disc injury/herniation or end plate fracture. Immediate pain indicates more severe injury. Stiffness is usually the result of muscle spasm. Shoulder pain may be the result of direct shoulder injury or referred pain from cervical disc injury (discogenic pain) or soft tissue injury (sclerotogenous pain). Headaches can result from injury to the upper cervical spine, reflex muscle spasm, TMJ dysfunction, the Barre-Lieou syndrome (rarely) or direct brain injury (i.e. postconcussion headaches). They may also have a vascular origin.
Interscapular pain may be due to direct injury to paraspinal muscles in this area but most often is due to muscle spasm or referred (sclerotogenous) pain from cervical soft tissues or from cervical discs. Later onset indicates myofascitis. Croft and Foreman1 found low back pain (LBP) in 57 percent of their CAD cases (71 percent in broadside collisions) while Braaf and Rosner2 noted LBP in 42 percent of their cases. Hohl3 described LBP in 35 percent of his cases. It is interesting though that in a long term follow up study of CAD victims, Watkins et al.4 found that while only 24 percent initially complained of LBP, after a mean of 10.8 years, 34 percent had LBP. Precise interpretation of this is difficult.
While parathesiae are usually blamed on direct nerve injury or irritation, thoracic outlet syndrome (which is probably an advanced manifestation of myofascitis) and sclertogenous pain can be associated with paresthesiae. Other causes include sympathetic disturbance and spinal cord injury. Extremity pain and weakness may be explained in the same way. Braaf and Rosner2 found sciatica in 15 percent of their cases.
It has been shown that dizziness and lightheadedness can be produced by injection of saline solution into the SCM muscle4. Muscular injury or vascular compromise due to increased sympathetic tone may have the same effect. Inner ear damage, such as a perilymph fistula, or a minor brain injury, may give the same symptom. Tinnitus may be the result of inner ear injury, TMJ injury/derangement or (rarely) Barre-Lieou syndrome. Phonophobia typically accompanies minor head injury. Vertigo usually indicates a labyrinthine pathology or brain stem disorder, although it can be due to ischemia. Short duration vertigo (5-10 sec.) associated with quick movements of the head is referred to a benign paroxysmal positional nystagmus (BPPN). This may be due to free floating otoconia which have been detached from the otolithic membrane. With abrupt movements of the head, they are swept up in the current of semicircular canal, causing displacement of the cupola. The resulting barrage of impulses causes BPPN, a condition sometimes referred to as cupolithiasis5,6.
Pupillary dilatation will often result in blurred vision and is generally the result of injury to the sympathetic system. Note that interruption of sympathetic fibers results in miosis e.g., Horner's syndrome. Irritation has the opposite effect. Nystagmus implicates the vestibular apparatus. Photophobia is common with mild head injury. Hildingsson et al.5 have proposed dysfunction of the proprioceptive system of the cervicocranial region as an explanation for visual tracking (smooth pursuit) abnormalities.
Dysphagia and/or hoarseness often is the result of swelling/spasm of the longus colli -- one of the chief culprits in straightening of the cervical lordotic curve. However, retrotracheal or retropharyngeal hematoma may give the same symptoms and should prompt immediate investigation. Hoarseness may also reflect direct laryngeal injury or injury to cranial nerves (brain stem lesions) or the recurrent laryngeal nerve.
Most often in CAD trauma, facial pain is due to a TMJ disorder (a.k.a. TMD). Associated clicking, popping, locking, limited opening, deviations, deflections, and palpable pain should prompt TMJ evaluation/referral.
Remember that delayed onset of symptoms is quite common following CAD trauma. Classic and contemporary writings have reflected this6-13. Some authors have described delays of months or even years2 although some of these conditions represent secondary adaptations to otherwise minimally symptomatic or asymptomatic conditions. Physicians who are cognizant of these numerous conditions and their protean manifestations will be best equipped to manage CAD trauma not only from the standpoint of diagnosis and treatment but also for medicolegal reasons.
- Foreman SM, Croft AC: Whiplash Injuries: The Cervical Acceleration/Deceleration Syndrome. Baltimore, Williams & Wilkins, 1988.
- Braaf MM, Rosner S: Symptomatology and treatment of injuries of the neck. NY State J Med 55: 237-242, 1955.
- Hohl M: Soft tissue injuries of the neck in automobile accidents: Factors influencing prognosis. J Bone Joint Surg 56A(8): 1675-1682, 1974.
- Macnab I: The "whiplash syndrome." Orth Clin N Amer 2(2): 389-403, 1971.
- Hildingsson C, Wenngren B-I, Bring G, Toolanen G: Oculomotor problems after cervical spine injury. Acta Orthop Scand 60(5): 513-516, 1989.
- Gotten N: Survey of one hundred cases of whiplash injury after settlement of litigation. JAMA 162(9): 865-867, 1956.
- Goldberg AC, Rothfus WE, Deeb ZL, Frankel DG, Wilberger JE Jr, Daffner RH: Hyperextension injuries of the cervical spine. Skeletal Radiol 18: 283-288, 1989.
- Green JD, Harle TS, Harris JH Jr: Anterior subluxation of the cervical spine: hyperflexion sprain. AJNR 2: 243-250, 1981.
- Evans DK: Anterior cervical subluxation. J Bone Joint Surg 58B (3): 318-321, 1976.
- Hildingson C, Toolanen G: Outcome after soft-tissue injury of the cervical spine. Acta Orthop Scand 61(4): 357-359, 1990.
- Schneider K, Zernicke RF, Clark G: Modeling of jaw-head-neck dynamics during whiplash. J Dent Res 68(9): 1360-1365, 1989.
- Croft AC: Whiplash. In Steigerwald DP, Croft AC (eds): Whiplash and Temporomandibular Joint Dysfunction: a Interdisciplinary Approach to Case Management. Encinitas, Keiser Publishing, 1992 (in press).
- Deans GT, Magalliard JN, Kerr M, Rutherford WH: Neck sprain -- a major cause of disability following care accidents. Injury 18: 10-12, 1987.
Arthur C. Croft, D.C., M.S., FACO
San Diego, California
If you are looking for more information on personal injury, consult Dr. Croft's video "Advances in Personal Injury Practice," #V-435 on the Preferred Reading and Viewing List, pages XXX.
Click here for more information about Arthur Croft, DC, MS, MPH, FACO.